# The refrigerator that needs the fewest repairs: why Rochester runs on top-freezers

Buying advice · By Rochester Appliance service team · Published November 16, 2026 · https://www.rochesterappliance.com/blog/most-reliable-refrigerator-style

> In our repair records, top-freezer refrigerators needed about one-eighth the repairs of French-door models in their second and third years. Here's what we found, why simpler holds up, and how to keep any refrigerator running.

## The short version

- Top-freezers are Rochester's workhorse: 64% of the refrigerators we've sold since 2020 whose style we know.
- In their second and third years, top-freezers needed 0.26 repairs per 100 refrigerators per year in our records. French doors needed 2.1, about 8 times more.
- More than half of our top-freezers go to landlords and property managers, the buyers who live with every repair bill.
- Ice makers are the weak spot. "Not making ice" needs a second visit more often than any other problem we fix (10.7%).

French-door refrigerators get the showroom spotlight. But the refrigerator Rochester actually buys most is the plain top-freezer, and our repair records show why.

## What Rochester buys

**Refrigerators sold since 2020, by style**

| Style | Refrigerators | Share |
| --- | ---: | ---: |
| Top-freezer | 4,639 | 64% |
| French door | 1,277 | 18% |
| Side-by-side | 842 | 12% |
| Bottom-freezer | 448 | 6% |

_Refrigerators whose style is recorded, sold from April 2020 through October 14, 2026._

More than half of our top-freezers go to landlords and property managers. They buy dozens of refrigerators and pay for every repair, so they choose what lasts.

## How each style holds up

We followed every refrigerator we've sold since 2020 for as long as it has been in service, and counted the repairs our technicians made for a failed part. We compare styles after the first year, once the factory warranty ends.

**Repairs per 100 refrigerators per year, years 2 and 3**

| Style | Repairs per 100 per year | Repairs / years of use |
| --- | ---: | ---: |
| Top-freezer | 0.26 | 15 in 5,816 |
| Bottom-freezer | 0.46 | 2 in 439 |
| Side-by-side | 1.0 | 12 in 1,180 |
| French door | 2.1 | 32 in 1,537 |

_Counts only repairs Rochester Appliance made on refrigerators it sold, so real-world rates are higher. The comparison between styles is what matters._

Put another way, a top-freezer in its second or third year needed a repair at about one-eighth the rate of a French door. The likely reason is what's built in. A top-freezer usually has one evaporator, one fan, a simple defrost system and often no ice maker or dispenser. Every added feature (through-the-door ice and water, multiple cooling zones, a drawer freezer, electronic controls) is one more thing that can fail.

## The ice maker is the weak spot

- The ice maker is the second most common refrigerator part to fail, behind only the evaporator fan motor.
- "Not making ice" needs a second visit for the same problem more often than any other problem we see: 10.7% of fixed repairs, against 5.4% overall.
- The water inlet valve and water lines that feed the ice maker add their own share of repairs.

> **Choosing a refrigerator.** If you don't need ice and water in the door, a top-freezer or bottom-freezer gives you the fewest repairs for your money. If you love a French door, it's still a good refrigerator. Just expect the ice maker to need attention at some point, and keep up with the care below.

## Keep any refrigerator running longer

- Vacuum the condenser coils twice a year, underneath or behind the refrigerator. Dusty coils make the compressor work harder.
- Change the water filter on schedule, usually every six months. A clogged filter starves the ice maker.
- Don't block the air vents inside the freezer and fresh-food sections. Overpacking causes frost and warm spots.
- Check the door gaskets. If a dollar bill slides out easily when the door is closed on it, the seal is leaking.
- If you never use the ice maker, turn it off as your owner's manual describes. Less running means less wear.

[Shop refrigerators](/refrigerators)

[Schedule a repair](/repair)

## Quick answers

### What is the most reliable type of refrigerator?

In Rochester Appliance's repair records, top-freezer refrigerators needed the fewest repairs: 0.26 per 100 refrigerators per year in their second and third years, compared with 2.1 for French-door models.

### Why do French-door refrigerators need more repairs?

They have more components: through-the-door ice and water, ice makers, more fans and electronic controls. Ice makers in particular are a frequent repair, and "not making ice" is the problem most likely to need a second visit.

### How can I make my refrigerator last longer?

Vacuum the condenser coils twice a year, change the water filter on schedule, keep the inside air vents clear, and check the door gaskets.

## How we got these numbers

From Rochester Appliance's own records: refrigerators sold since 2020, followed through October 14, 2026, and the repairs our technicians made on them.

- Rochester Appliance sales records: refrigerators sold from April 2020 through October 14, 2026 whose style (top-freezer, bottom-freezer, side-by-side or French door) is recorded.
- Rochester Appliance service records: repairs for a failed part on those refrigerators, counted per 100 refrigerators per year of use in their second and third years. Each repair case is counted once.
- Second-visit rate: the share of fixed repairs that needed another visit for the same problem within 30 days, June 2014 through October 14, 2026.
